The Macallan Edition No. 4: Our Review and the Price

The Macallan Edition No. 4, single malt du Speyside, Le Caveau des Pépites

The verdict in 50 words

The 2018 edition, released for the opening of the new distillery. Lighter and fresher than the other releases, with a pronounced American oak character. It is by far the best value for money in the Edition series.

Who it is and isn't for

For you if you want to get into the Edition series without paying the price of No. 1, if you like fresh and fruity Speysides, or if you are looking for a bottle to open rather than keep.

Pass it by if you are looking for dense Macallan sherry: try the 1824 Series Ruby. And if you are buying for your collection, the No. 1 remains the benchmark.

Our pick for this article

The architecture edition

In 2018, Macallan opened a production building designed by Rogers Stirk Harbour: a curved roof covered with grassland, nestled in the Easter Elchies hillside. Edition No. 4 was created to mark the occasion, and its green packaging reflects the construction site.

The theme is more than just a packaging gimmick: the blend is light and approachable, while other releases in the series aim for greater intensity. It is a coherent choice that reflects what it celebrates.

The distillery

The Macallan uses the smallest stills in Speyside and retains only a small fraction of the heart of the distillation. The resulting spirit is intense, allowing for long sherry maturation. The casks are made to order, then seasoned in sherry for several years in Jerez bodegas before being filled. No Macallan whisky is artificially coloured.

The nose

Vanilla and American oak are at the forefront, followed by crisp green apple, lemon zest and a hint of coconut typical of this wood. Sherry remains in the background, presenting as blonde grape rather than dried fruit. The overall impression is fresh and direct.

The palate

A bright and lively start, with golden caramel, honey and pear in the middle. Spices arrive late and remain gentle, with cinnamon and fresh ginger. The finish is medium, clean and slightly peppery, without bitterness.

It is a daytime Macallan, if that expression has any meaning: approachable, balanced and effortless.

The downside, because there is one

It is the least intense release in the series. If you expect the complexity of a long sherry, you will be disappointed: American oak dominates and the whisky gives up its flavours quickly, with no second reading.

For this reason, it is also the least sought-after of the six by collectors. That is bad news if you are buying to resell, and excellent news if you are buying to drink: you are paying for the liquid, not its rarity.

Finally, as with the entire house, provenance matters: Macallan is one of the most counterfeited whisky brands. Our bottles come from identified professional channels and are inspected upon arrival.

Serving and pairings

At room temperature, in a tulip glass, neat. It is one of the few Macallans that takes a few drops of water well, bringing out the white fruit. Store the bottle upright and away from light.

At the table: apple tart, crème brûlée, hard cheeses and dried fruit. It also works very well as an aperitif, which is unusual for the house.

The summary

Distillery The Macallan, Easter Elchies, Speyside
Year and theme 2018, opening of the new Rogers Stirk Harbour distillery
Nose Vanilla, green apple, lemon, coconut
Palate Lively, golden caramel, honey and pear, clean finish
The downside The least intense in the series, little sought after by collectors

Our verdict: the bottle to open in the series. Keep No. 1 sealed if you are collecting, and drink this one.

The Macallan Edition No. 4

70 cl · Carefully packaged with excellent protection to ensure your bottles arrive in perfect condition · Pay in installments with Klarna

View the bottle and order

More than 1,000 customers have already trusted us, with an average rating of 4.9 out of 5.

Other editions and alternatives

Review written by the Caveau des Pépites team based on the distillery's style, the blend's composition and the bottles that pass through our cellar. Excessive alcohol consumption is harmful to health; drink responsibly.

Back to blog

Our picks related to this article

Explore the whole cellar